I had such hopes for ABC’s new Shat-centric prime time game show, Show Me the Money. Indeed, I blogged those hopes here.
Well, it premiered last night, and I couldn’t make it through 30 minutes. It’s dreadful. More than dreadful. It’s embarrassing.
Shattered dreams. Shattered, Shatnered dreams.
The problem isn’t Bill Shatner, not by a long shot. (Although there was a painfully awkward moment when he offered props to a flamboyantly gay contestant and told him how much he respected his bravery. Weird.)
No, the problem is that the game mechanics of Show Me the Money are bloody awful. Truly it is most ill-conceived game show I’ve ever seen. And I watched The Chair.
(FYI, if you are questioning my qualifications for commenting on the quality of game shows, be aware that my first words were “Bob Barker.”)
Let me set up the premise: 12 beautiful models/dancers each hold a scroll emblazoned with a dollar amount, ranging from $20,000 to $250,000. A 13th model/dancer holds a “Killer” scroll which, according to Bill, you MUST. NOT. PICK. The scrolls are rolled up and randomized so you don’t know which girl is holding which amount.
The contestant has to answer a pop culture question (refreshingly not multiple choice, but that’s ALL that’s refreshing). Then he picks a model, who opens her scroll, revealing its amount. If the contestant answers the question correctly, his “bank” is increased by the amount on that model’s scroll. If he’s wrong, his “bank” is decreased by the amount on the scroll.
The contestant continues answering questions and opening scrolls until he answers six questions correctly, or six questions incorrectly. At that point, the contestant goes home with whatever’s in his bank.
If the contestant picks the “Killer” scroll, then the game stops immediately and he must answer ONE. LAST. QUESTION. If the contestant misses the Killer Question, he immediately loses all his money and the game is over. If he answers it correctly, the game continues as before.
And that’s it.
I didn’t think it was possible to create a more mind-numbingly inane game than Deal or No Deal, a show that requires no skill or knowledge or intelligence of ANY kind, and yet…here it is.
If you consider the rules…and watched the show…the primary problem plaguing Show Me the Money quickly becomes apparent:
It’s a game show without a game.
Is that not the ultimate crime? Let’s break this down:
1) The show creates absolutely no drama whatsoever. The critical element of the popular modern game show (Deal or No Deal, Who Wants to be a Millionaire, etc.) is that at some point the contestant is forced to make a decision to put all his money on the line. Answer the question or don’t. Open the case or don’t. The drama comes from the contestant having to make a choice. As viewers, we become emotionally involved, debating that decision with our family and friends.
On Show Me the Money, a contestant chooses NOTHING. He MUST continue playing until correctly answers six questions or misses six questions. He’s just going through the motions – the contestant can’t stop, and either he’s going to know the answer or not, so where’s the drama? The tension? There’s no debate to be had in the living room! How do WE participate?
Case in point: The aforementioned flamboyantly gay contestant had banked $500,000 by the time he reached his final question. It was a ridiculously easy pop culture question (shouldn’t the last question be the hardest one??) which he clearly answered correctly. The scroll contained $20,000. Well at that point, who cares if he loses $20,000? What’s the difference between $500,000 and $480,000?
So on the first question he won $220,000, and on the last question – the riveting climax – he won an additional $20,000.
Wheeeeeeeeee. What a build-up!
2) Imagine if you played Candy Land, and one of the cards read “You Lose, Stop Playing Now.” That would make for a satisfying experience, wouldn’t it?
The “Killer” scroll/question is basically an automatic lose card. It’s way too arbitrary. If a contestant is going to be knocked out of the game, it should be because the contestant CHOSE to risk something.
Last night, the second contestant, a perfectly pleasant US Marine, was up to about $400,000 when he picked the Model with the Killer scroll. He got the question wrong. Bam. He was done. All Bill Shatner could say was “Um, well, thanks for serving your country. Sorry about that.”
The whole thing is ludicrous. Why not double the number of models, and as a contestant gets further into the game, more and more money scrolls get replaced with Killer scrolls. Choosing a model becomes walking a minefield. Give the contestant the CHOICE of continuing or not, knowing that the more he plays, the more likely he is to hit a Killer scroll.
Or if you aren’t going to give him a choice, then at least give the guy a reward for getting the question right – double his bank or something. Make it mean SOMETHING.
3) The show moves at a glacial pace. Think Deal or No Deal moves slowly? On Show Me the Money, each time the contestant is presented with a question, he has the option of passing it. He can do this twice for each question, and then he must answer the third.
So first we have to listen to the contestant drone on about how he doesn’t know the name of Russell Crowe’s character in A Beautiful Mind, and then whine about how he doesn’t know who appeared nude on Broadway four years ago, and then he finally gets to the question he’s actually going to answer. It can take up to ten minutes to get through just one question. I’d rather watch two American Idol results shows than listen to that. It’s unbearable.
4) Dollar amounts are too similar. There’s $250,000, $220,000, $190,000, and on down. There’s no “uber” scroll to get excited about. The show needs a “massive” amount like a $500,000 scroll to add to the excitement.
5) The models hate their jobs. I know this isn’t technically part of the game, but if you look closely at the models/dancers, they seem miserable. Compare them to the Deal or No Deal ladies, who are inexplicably euphoric to have a job opening briefcases at Howie Mandel’s command. Why are the Show Me the Money dancers so angry?
Show Me the Money is unsalvageable. Seriously. Get out of there, Shatner! Get out now! We’ll still love you, and we’ll still tune into Boston Legal every Tuesday night. We’ll chalk it up to the Mad Cow Disease.