This post is in large part a response to the Rocky Balboa review posted by our friends at YAYSports NBA. We suggest that before you read this post that you 1) See the movie Rocky Balboa and 2) Read the YAYSports! write-up, which is very funny, profoundly negative, and couched in basketball references we don’t understand.
Here’s the deal: we really, really loved Rocky Balboa (just like my MOM and my SISTER), and feel obliged to defend it.
1) YAY! contends that Rocky Balboa is an “ill-conceived, poorly done rehash of the original movie”.
No argument that it’s a rehash of the original, but I don’t buy “ill-conceived” or “poorly done.” It starts with a premise that can be described in two words (“Adrian died”) and everything flows naturally from there. Nothing is contrived or unbelievable. It’s feels right. It’s feels real. It asks the question “Why would one of the most famous sports figures on the planet spend his golden years in lower middle class mediocrity?” and answers it thusly: Rocky stays in Philadelphia (where we left him in Rocky V) because it’s where Adrian died, and since he owes all the success in his life to her (or so he’s made himself believe), he remains there. He opens a restaurant where he can live in perpetually in the past, forever retelling tales of his glory days, and be constantly reminded of her. Sly sells it beautifully.
The core difference between this film and the original is that Rocky has to figure out how to succeed without Adrian. When he does, it’s emotional and satisfying and the perfect bookend to the series.
(Sidenote: You want an ill-conceived, poorly done rehash of the original movie? Superman Returns, baby — it’s just pointless.)
2) YAY! contends the training sequence and the fight scene were badly done.
Mostly agreed on the training sequence. Although, I loved Rocky’s trainer cracking his neck, saying “Let’s make some hurting bombs” followed by the transition into the Rocky theme. Gave me chills. The actual montage was lackluster, but let’s be honest. How were they going to top the “Homoerotic Beach Frolicking with Apollo Creed” in Rocky III, or the “Burying the KGB in an Avalanche / Growing a Thick Beard” sequence in Rocky IV? Wasn’t gonna happen.
As for the fight, well, it was okay, but you can’t tell me the “Rocky gets up one last time” scene wasn’t beautiful. Because it was. Beautiful like Apollo Creed glistening in the California surf.
3) YAY! contends Rocky Jr. makes no sense.
I won’t step on your hilarious line, which is hilarious, but I will say this: I suspect Rocky and Adrian set up a trust fund for Rocky Jr., which would have been unaffected by their accountant’s financial shenanigans in Rocky V. Rocky Jr. doesn’t need to work, but does so to be his own man. He can afford to take the time off and find himself. With Steps, the Jamaican badboy.
4) YAY! contends Rocky pouncing on Dixon’s broken hand was horrible, horrible, horrible.
Was it the original Rocky or Rocky II where Apollo breaks a rib and Mickey tells Rocky to “punch him in the broken rib” and Rocky replies “Great idea, Mickey, I think I’ll punch him in the broken rib because it will give me an advantage.” So there’s a precedent. Besides, the dialogue makes it clear that once Dixon’s hand “numbs up” it wouldn’t be a factor. And Rocky lost the fight, so ultimately it didn’t matter one bit.
5) YAY! likes Rocky V better than Rocky Balboa.
Well this is just silly. Rocky V commits the worst sin a sequel can commit: It betrays its predecessor. I think we’re in agreement that Rocky IV is AWESOME. But 20 minutes into Rocky V, we learn that 1) Rocky suffered irreversible brain damage during his fight with Drago and 2) Rocky’s accountant took advantage of Rocky’s absence to swindle him out of his fortune. Rocky V ruined Rocky IV for me. For 15 years, I couldn’t watch Rocky IV without being reminded that while Rocky is in Russia performing all these glorious and superheroic feats, he’s becoming a destitute vegetable.
(It’s exactly what happened with Alien 3, when Newt and Hicks were killed, offscreen, in the first three minutes of the film.)
Rocky Balboa undoes both those atrocities AND, to its credit, still manages to include V in the mythology. Did you catch when Rocky said “Home Team” to his son? That’s a callback for the fans. Thanks, Sly.
In conclusion, while we generally agree with YAYSports!’s (what is the possessive form of YAYSports! by the way?) entertainment analyses, this time, we just can’t. They are WAY off base. Even my sister says so, and my sister hates every movie made since Back to the Future, Part II.